My post content

The Two I’m Fines

For a long time, I thought “I’m fine” was a lie.

Or at least a soft evasion — something people said when they didn’t want to explain, or didn’t have the energy, or didn’t trust the listener with the truth.

I heard it used that way all the time.

And I used it that way too.

What I didn’t understand then was that there isn’t just one I’m fine.

There are two.

—

The first one is social.

This is the I’m fine you say in passing — at the grocery store, on the sidewalk, in the brief exchange where someone asks how you are but doesn’t actually want an answer that would stop the world.

This I’m fine keeps things moving.

It preserves the container.

It says:

I am functioning enough to be here.

This version isn’t dishonest.

It’s economical.

It doesn’t mean nothing is wrong.

It means this moment isn’t designed to hold what’s real.

It’s a boundary disguised as politeness.

And for a long time,

it was the only one I had.

—

Then there is the second I’m fine.

This one is quieter.

It doesn’t show up early.

You don’t use it until you’ve lived through enough days where fine felt completely out of reach.

This I’m fine doesn’t mean I feel good.

It doesn’t mean I’m better.

It doesn’t mean anything has resolved.

It means:

I am not in crisis right now.

It means:

I am steady enough to be here.

It means:

Within the limits of this body, this day, this moment — I am okay.

—

That distinction took me years to learn.

For a long time, when I said I’m fine, people assumed I was minimizing.

Or denying.

Or trying to sound brave.

In illness spaces especially, the phrase can trigger suspicion — as if you owe proof of suffering in order to be believed.

But what I eventually realized was that saying more often came at a cost.

Explaining required energy I didn’t always have.

Detail invited fixing.

Honesty was often met with disbelief or discomfort.

Sometimes I’m fine was the most respectful answer I could give —

to myself.

—

The mistake people make is thinking fine is a verdict.

It isn’t.

It’s a status report.

And like any status report,

it depends on context.

Early on, my I’m fine was armor.

It helped me move through the world without collapsing into explanation.

Later, it became something else entirely —

a way of naming stability without pretending to be healed.

The second I’m fine isn’t performative.

It’s precise.

It says:

I know where I am today.

Not better.

Not worse.

Here.

—

Learning the difference between those two meanings changed how I spoke —

and how I listened.

It taught me that language doesn’t just convey truth;

it protects it.

And sometimes the most honest thing you can say

is the sentence that keeps you intact.

Now, when I say I’m fine,

I know which one I mean.

This story lives in Compass Point 3 — Who Stands With Me Now?